Quashing an FIR in the High Court Under BNSS Section 528
A High Court can end a criminal case at the FIR stage, but only on settled grounds. Here is what section 528 of the BNSS says, when courts quash on settlement, and when compounding in the trial court is enough.
A High Court can quash an FIR, a criminal complaint or the proceedings that follow from them under its inherent powers, which are preserved by section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS). This is the provision that replaced section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 from 1 July 2024, and the case law decided under section 482 continues to guide courts. The power is used sparingly. In broad terms, a High Court will quash when the FIR, read as it stands, does not disclose an offence or the case is an abuse of process, or when the parties have genuinely settled a dispute that is essentially private or civil in nature.
If every offence in the FIR is compoundable, there may be no need to go to the High Court at all, because the trial court can record a compromise under section 359 of the BNSS. This guide explains both routes and what goes into the paperwork. A quashing petition is argued in the High Court, so in practice you will need an advocate who appears there.
What section 528 actually says
Nothing in this Sanhita shall be deemed to limit or affect the inherent powers of the High Court to make such orders as may be necessary to give effect to any order under this Sanhita, or to prevent abuse of the process of any Court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice.
Section 528, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023
The wording is the same in substance as the old section 482. As the Supreme Court explained in Parbatbhai Aahir v State of Gujarat (2017), the provision does not create new powers; it recognises powers that inhere in the High Court. Petitions are also filed under Article 226 of the Constitution, and the Supreme Court's guidance applies to both.
When a High Court will quash: the Bhajan Lal categories
The leading statement of the grounds is State of Haryana v Bhajan Lal (1990), reported in 1992. The Supreme Court listed, by way of illustration, the kinds of cases in which the power may be used to prevent abuse of process or to secure the ends of justice. In plain terms they are:
- The allegations in the FIR or complaint, even if taken at face value and accepted in full, do not make out any offence.
- The allegations and accompanying material do not disclose a cognizable offence that would justify police investigation without a Magistrate's order.
- The uncontroverted allegations and the evidence collected do not disclose any offence.
- The allegations disclose only a non-cognizable offence, which the police cannot investigate without a Magistrate's order (now section 174(2) of the BNSS).
- The allegations are so absurd and inherently improbable that no prudent person could conclude there is sufficient ground to proceed.
- An express legal bar in the Code or the relevant Act prevents the case from being started or continued, or the Act gives a specific and effective remedy.
- The proceeding is manifestly malicious, brought with an ulterior motive to wreak vengeance or out of a private grudge.
The court stressed that these are illustrations, not a closed list. In practice, many successful petitions show that the dispute is a civil one dressed up as a crime. For cheating, for example, the Supreme Court said in Vijay Kumar Ghai v State of West Bengal (2022) that the complainant must show a prima facie intention to cheat from the inception; a later failure to keep a promise is a breach of contract, not cheating.
What the High Court will not do
In Neeharika Infrastructure v State of Maharashtra (2021), a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court restated the limits. Among its conclusions:
- Quashing should be the exception rather than the ordinary rule, and criminal proceedings ought not to be scuttled at the initial stage.
- The court does not inquire into the reliability or genuineness of the allegations at this stage, and only asks whether the FIR discloses a cognizable offence.
- An FIR is not an encyclopaedia that must contain every detail; the police should normally be allowed to complete the investigation.
- Interim orders of "no coercive steps" or stay of investigation should not be passed routinely, and an accused will ordinarily be left to apply for anticipatory bail, which is now section 482 of the BNSS.
The power is not confined to the FIR stage. In Anand Kumar Mohatta v State (NCT of Delhi) (2018), the Supreme Court held that a High Court can quash proceedings even after the police have filed a charge sheet, observing that an abuse of process is aggravated, not cured, when the FIR turns into a charge sheet.
Quashing after a settlement
Many FIRs arise from business, money or family disputes that the parties later resolve. If the offences are compoundable, the trial court can record the compromise. If they are not, only the High Court can end the case, and Gian Singh v State of Punjab (2012) sets out when it will.
the power of the High Court in quashing a criminal proceeding or FIR or complaint in exercise of its inherent jurisdiction is distinct and different from the power given to a criminal court for compounding the offences under Section 320 of the Code.
Gian Singh v State of Punjab (2012)
The court went on to hold that heinous and serious offences such as murder, rape and dacoity cannot fittingly be quashed even if the victim's family has settled, because they are not private in nature and affect society. Settlements cannot be the basis for quashing offences under special statutes such as the Prevention of Corruption Act, or offences by public servants in that capacity. On the other hand, cases with an overwhelmingly civil flavour, particularly those arising from commercial, financial, partnership or similar transactions, or from matrimony and family disputes where the wrong is basically private, may be quashed if conviction is remote and continuing the case would be oppressive. Parbatbhai Aahir (2017) restated the same principles.
A private compromise does not close the FIR
Signing a settlement with the complainant does not end the criminal case. Until the trial court records a valid composition or the High Court passes a quashing order, the FIR and any proceedings continue, and missing a court date can still lead to a warrant. Keep attending, and file the compromise in the correct court promptly.
Compounding under section 359: when the trial court is enough
Section 359 of the BNSS replaces section 320 of the old Code. It contains two tables of offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS):
- The first table lists offences the victim can compound without the court's permission, such as voluntarily causing hurt under section 115(2) of the BNS and cheating under section 318(2).
- The second table lists offences that can be compounded only with the permission of the court where the prosecution is pending, such as criminal breach of trust under section 316(2) and cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of property under section 318(4).
- Under section 359(8), a composition has the effect of an acquittal, and under section 359(9) no offence can be compounded except as the section provides.
- After committal for trial or conviction with an appeal pending, composition needs the leave of the court concerned, and an accused who faces enhanced punishment because of a previous conviction cannot compound.
So the first step is to list every section in the FIR and check each one against both tables. If all of them appear, a compounding application before the trial court, signed by the person entitled to compound, is usually faster and cheaper than a High Court petition. If even one offence is in neither table, the trial court cannot accept the compromise for it, and the route is a quashing petition.
Preparing a quashing petition
Each High Court has its own rules on format, court fee and filing, so the details vary. The core content is similar everywhere:
- Obtain a copy of the FIR, and of the charge sheet and the trial court's summoning order if the case has moved that far. An FIR copy request helps if you do not already have one.
- Identify the ground: which Bhajan Lal category applies, or that the parties have settled a dispute of a private or civil nature.
- Draft the petition with a short chronology, the legal grounds, and the relief sought (quashing of the FIR and all consequential proceedings).
- If the ground is settlement, attach the written settlement and an affidavit from the complainant confirming it was voluntary and that they do not object to quashing. Be prepared for the High Court to ask the complainant to appear or be identified, since the court will want to be satisfied that the settlement is genuine.
- Make the State (through the police station or Public Prosecutor) and the complainant respondents, and sign a vakalatnama in favour of your advocate.
- Ask for interim relief only if there is a real basis for it, keeping in mind the Neeharika guidance, and consider anticipatory bail separately if arrest is a risk.
What the settlement document should say
When the petition rests on a compromise, the written settlement is the document the judge reads most closely. A vague one-page note invites questions about whether the complainant really agreed. A clear compromise petition or settlement deed usually covers:
- The names and addresses of the parties, and the FIR number, police station, date and sections invoked.
- The background of the dispute in a few neutral sentences, without either side admitting to a crime.
- The terms: any amount paid or payable and how, return of goods or documents, and arrangements about children or property in family cases.
- A statement that the complainant has settled voluntarily, without pressure, and has no objection to the FIR and all consequential proceedings being quashed.
- Undertakings by both sides to withdraw or not pursue related complaints, civil suits or applications arising from the same facts.
- Signatures of both parties with dates, and witnesses.
A quashing order covers only the case placed before the court. If the same dispute has produced more than one FIR, a private complaint, or a civil case, list them all in the settlement and deal with each in the right forum, so that nothing is left running after the main FIR ends. Where money is payable in instalments, think about how the settlement will be enforced if a later instalment is missed, because the criminal case may already have been closed by then.
Start the petition
Prepare a quashing petition that sets out the FIR details, the grounds and the settlement, if any, for your advocate to finalise.
Draft a quashing petitionBecause the petition is argued in the High Court, it is worth consulting a criminal lawyer early. If you are still at the stage of a complaint that the police have not registered, our guide on what to do when the police refuse an FIR is the better starting point, and LegalFirms explains how anticipatory bail works if you fear arrest while the petition is pending.
Frequently asked questions
Is section 528 of the BNSS the same as section 482 of the CrPC?
In substance, yes. The wording preserving the High Court's inherent powers is carried over, and the Supreme Court's judgments under section 482, including Bhajan Lal, Gian Singh and Neeharika, continue to guide how the power is used. The new section number applies to proceedings under the BNSS from 1 July 2024.
Can an FIR be quashed after the charge sheet is filed?
Yes. In Anand Kumar Mohatta (2018) the Supreme Court held that the High Court's power is not limited to the FIR stage and can be used after a charge sheet has been filed, where the case otherwise meets the grounds for quashing.
Can a dowry or matrimonial case be quashed after the couple settles?
It can be, depending on the facts. Gian Singh specifically mentions offences arising out of matrimony relating to dowry and family disputes where the wrong is basically private as cases that may be quashed after a full settlement. The High Court still looks at the nature of the allegations and whether the settlement is genuine and complete.
Do I need a quashing petition if the offence is compoundable?
Usually not. If every offence in the FIR appears in one of the tables in section 359 of the BNSS, the compromise can be recorded by the trial court, with its permission where the second table applies. A High Court petition is needed when at least one offence is non-compoundable or when you are relying on grounds other than settlement.
What if the High Court dismisses the petition?
The case continues in the trial court, where you can still raise your defences, including at the stage of discharge. A dismissal can also be challenged before the Supreme Court by a special leave petition, which is discretionary.
Sources
The official texts this guide relies on. Laws and rules change, so check the current version before relying on any of them.
- Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (Ministry of Home Affairs)
- State of Haryana v Ch. Bhajan Lal, Supreme Court, 21 November 1990
- Gian Singh v State of Punjab, Supreme Court, 24 September 2012
- Parbatbhai Aahir v State of Gujarat, Supreme Court, 4 October 2017
- Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt Ltd v State of Maharashtra, Supreme Court, 13 April 2021
- Anand Kumar Mohatta v State (NCT of Delhi), Supreme Court, 15 November 2018
- Vijay Kumar Ghai v State of West Bengal, Supreme Court, 22 March 2022
Documents to draft next
Real templates from our library, matched to what this guide covers.
You might also want to read
Default Bail Under BNSS Section 187: When Police Miss the Deadline
If the police do not file a charge sheet within 60 or 90 days of remand, the accused gets a right to bail that does not depend on the merits. The right is lost if it is not claimed in time.
How to Get a Certified Copy of a Court Order or Judgment
A certified copy comes from the court's copying section with a signed and sealed certificate. Here is how to apply, what urgent and online copies mean, and why the date you apply matters for an appeal.
Maintenance Under BNSS Section 144: Wife, Children and Parents
Section 144 of the BNSS lets a wife, children and parents who cannot support themselves claim a monthly allowance from a person with means who neglects them. Here is who qualifies, how the amount is fixed and how orders are enforced.
