Leave and Licence vs Rent Agreement: The Difference That Matters
A rent agreement usually creates a lease, which gives the occupier an interest in the property. A leave and licence only gives permission to use it. Courts look at what the document actually does, not what it is called.
A rent agreement normally creates a lease, which transfers to the tenant a right to enjoy the property for a period in return for rent. A leave and licence agreement only gives the occupier permission to use the premises, while the owner keeps legal possession. The difference decides what rights the occupier has when the arrangement ends, but the title on the document does not settle it. Courts look at what the document actually does. In Maharashtra there is one more rule that catches many people: every leave and licence agreement must be in writing and registered.
The two definitions
The two arrangements come from different laws.
- Lease: section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 defines a lease of immovable property as a transfer of a right to enjoy the property, for a certain time or in perpetuity, in consideration of a price paid or promised or of rent paid periodically. The tenant gets an interest in the property.
- Licence: section 52 of the Indian Easements Act, 1882 defines a licence as a right to do something on another person's property that would otherwise be unlawful, where that right does not amount to an easement or an interest in the property. The licensee gets permission, not an interest.
Other provisions of the Easements Act follow from that. A licence generally cannot be transferred by the licensee (section 56). It can be revoked by the grantor unless it is coupled with a transfer of property or the licensee has, acting on it, built something of a permanent character at his own expense (section 60). When a licence is revoked, the licensee gets a reasonable time to leave and remove his belongings (section 63).
The label does not decide it
Owners sometimes call a document a leave and licence hoping to avoid tenancy protection. Courts look past the name. The classic statement of the test is in Justice Subba Rao's opinion in Associated Hotels of India Ltd v. R.N. Kapoor (1959), and Justice S.K. Das agreed with him that the document in that case, though drafted as a licence, was really a lease.
(1) To ascertain whether a document creates a licence or lease, the substance of the document must be preferred to the form ; (2) the real test is the intention of the parties-whether they intended to create a lease or a licence; (3) if the document creates an interest in the property, it is a lease;
Subba Rao J., Associated Hotels of India Ltd v. R.N. Kapoor, Supreme Court (1959)
The same opinion adds that if the document only permits another to use the property while legal possession stays with the owner, it is a licence, and that exclusive possession points prima facie to a tenancy, though other circumstances can show that no lease was intended. In that case the occupier had exclusive possession of the rooms, free of the owner's control, and could even transfer his interest with consent. That was treated as inconsistent with a licence.
Calling it a licence is not enough
A document headed leave and licence that hands over exclusive possession of a flat for years, lets the occupier sublet, and reads like a lease in every clause may be treated as a lease. If you want a genuine licence, the terms have to match: the owner keeps legal possession, the permission is personal to the licensee, and it cannot be transferred.
Why the difference matters when the arrangement ends
A tenant may have the protection of the State's rent control law, which can restrict eviction to specified grounds and route disputes to a rent controller or court. A licensee usually has no such protection in a contract governed only by the Easements Act: once the licence is validly revoked or expires, the licensee must leave after a reasonable time. Rent laws are State laws and their coverage differs, so the exact position depends on where the property is and what the State law says about licensees.
Maharashtra shows how a State can deal with licences directly. Section 24 of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 says a licensee of residential premises must hand back possession when the licence period expires. If he does not, the landlord can apply to the Competent Authority for an eviction order, and the licensee who stays on is liable to pay damages at double the licence fee until he is removed. The same section says a written licence agreement is conclusive evidence of the facts stated in it.
Maharashtra: registration is compulsory
Section 55 of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 requires every agreement for leave and licence or letting of premises made after the Act came into force to be in writing and registered under the Registration Act, 1908, whatever its duration. It puts three consequences on the landlord.
- The duty to get the agreement registered is the landlord's.
- If there is no written registered agreement, the occupier's version of the terms will prevail unless proved otherwise.
- A landlord who contravenes the section can be punished with imprisonment up to three months, a fine up to five thousand rupees, or both.
Maharashtra's Stamp Act also has its own entry for leave and licence agreements, Article 36A, which calculates the duty on the licence fee and the deposit. Check the current rate before you pay it.
Outside Maharashtra: the 11-month practice
Section 17(1)(d) of the Registration Act, 1908 makes registration compulsory for leases of immovable property from year to year, for any term exceeding one year, or reserving a yearly rent. That is why many rent agreements are written for eleven months. Keeping the term under a year avoids compulsory registration under the central Act, but it does not avoid stamp duty, which is payable under the State's stamp law on the agreement. Rates, the method of calculation and any State-specific registration rules differ from State to State, so check them for the place where the property is. Our guide on rent agreement stamp duty and registration covers this in more detail.
Choosing and preparing the right document
- Decide what you are actually granting. If the occupier will have exclusive possession of a flat or shop for a fixed period in return for monthly payments, a rent agreement that openly creates a lease is often the honest choice.
- If the owner will keep legal possession and is only allowing use, for example a paying guest room or a desk in an office, a licence fits. For business premises, a licence agreement for commercial space is drafted for that purpose.
- In Maharashtra, use a leave and licence agreement and register it, whatever the term.
- Write down the period, the licence fee or rent, the deposit and when it will be refunded, who pays maintenance and utilities, the notice period, and what happens on expiry.
- Pay the stamp duty that applies in your State before or at the time of signing, and register the document where the law requires it or where the term exceeds one year.
- Keep the registered or stamped original, the payment receipts and any handover inventory together.
Draft your leave and licence agreement
Set out the period, licence fee, deposit and exit terms in one clear document.
Draft a leave and licence agreementWhen the occupier will not leave
A dispute over whether an occupier is a tenant or a licensee usually ends up before a rent authority or a civil court, and the answer turns on the document and the facts. Read questions other owners and occupiers have asked, and if the matter is heading to court, speak to a property lawyer who practises in the State where the property is.
Frequently asked questions
Is a leave and licence agreement valid outside Maharashtra?
Yes. The concept of a licence comes from section 52 of the Indian Easements Act, 1882, which is a central law. The term leave and licence is most common in Maharashtra because its rent law uses it, but a licence can be granted anywhere. What changes from State to State is the stamp duty, any registration rule and how the local rent law treats licensees.
Does an 11-month agreement mean I never have to register it?
Under section 17(1)(d) of the Registration Act, 1908, leases for a term exceeding one year must be registered, so a shorter term is outside that clause. It still needs proper stamp duty under State law. In Maharashtra, section 55 of the Rent Control Act requires registration of every leave and licence agreement regardless of its length.
Can a licensee claim to be a tenant later?
He can try, and courts will look at the substance of the arrangement. If the document and the facts show exclusive possession and an interest in the property, the court may treat it as a lease despite the label. If the owner kept legal possession and only allowed use, the claim is unlikely to succeed.
What happens to the deposit when a licence ends?
The Easements Act does not deal with deposits, so the agreement decides. Write down the amount, what can be deducted and the date by which the balance will be returned. If the deposit is not refunded, the remedy is a demand notice followed by a civil claim.
Who is responsible for registering the agreement in Maharashtra?
Section 55(2) of the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 puts that responsibility on the landlord. If the agreement is not registered, the occupier's account of the terms prevails unless the landlord proves otherwise, and the landlord can also face prosecution under section 55(3).
Sources
The official texts this guide relies on. Laws and rules change, so check the current version before relying on any of them.
- Transfer of Property Act, 1882, section 105
- Indian Easements Act, 1882, section 52 (and sections 56, 60, 63)
- Associated Hotels of India Ltd v. R.N. Kapoor, Supreme Court, 19 May 1959
- Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999, section 55
- Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999, section 24
- Registration Act, 1908, section 17
- Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958, Schedule I, Article 36A
Documents to draft next
Real templates from our library, matched to what this guide covers.
You might also want to read
Rent Agreement in India: Stamp Duty, Registration and the Clauses That Actually Matter
Stamp duty, registration, security deposits and notice periods differ by state and by contract type. Here's what actually determines whether your rent agreement holds up.
Gifting Property to Family: Registration, Acceptance, Revocation
A gift of property to a relative needs a registered deed, two attesting witnesses and acceptance in the donor's lifetime. Once complete it is very hard to undo, unless the law on senior citizens applies.
Gift Deed vs Sale Deed: Which One Actually Transfers Property Correctly
A gift deed and a sale deed both transfer title, but stamp duty, tax treatment and reversibility differ sharply, and several states tax gifts very differently depending on who the recipient is.
