Legal Drive

Trademark Objection: How to Reply to the Examination Report

A trademark examination report lists the Registry's objections under section 9 or section 11 of the Trade Marks Act. You have one month to reply or ask for a hearing, or the application can be treated as abandoned.

9 min readPublished 19 November 2026 IST

When the Trade Marks Registry examines your application and has a problem with it, it issues an examination report. The objections usually fall under section 9 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 (absolute grounds, about the mark itself) or section 11 (relative grounds, about conflict with earlier marks). Under rule 33(4) of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017 you must reply within one month from the date you receive the report. If you do not, the Registrar may treat the application as abandoned. A reply that does not satisfy the examiner leads to a hearing before the application is accepted or refused.

This guide explains what the report means, how to answer each kind of objection, what evidence helps, and what happens after you reply. If you have not filed yet, start with our guide to trademark registration.

What the examination report is

Rule 33 sets out the process. The Registrar examines the application under the Act, including a search of earlier registered and pending marks for identical or deceptively similar marks covering the same or similar goods or services. If there is an objection, or if the Registrar is willing to accept the mark only with conditions, amendments or limitations under section 18(4), the applicant is told in writing through the examination report. If there is no objection, the application is accepted and sent for advertisement in the Trade Marks Journal.

Download the report from the IP India portal and note the date it was issued and the date you received it, because the one-month period runs from receipt.

within one month from the date of receipt of the examination report

Rule 33(4), Trade Marks Rules, 2017

Absolute grounds: objections under section 9

Section 9 objections are about whether the mark can work as a trademark at all. Common grounds include:

  • The mark is devoid of distinctive character, so it cannot distinguish your goods or services from others'.
  • The mark consists only of words that describe the kind, quality, quantity, purpose, value, geographical origin or time of production of the goods or services (for example, "Fresh Bakes" for bakery products).
  • The mark consists only of words that have become customary in the current language or trade practice.
  • The mark is likely to deceive or cause confusion, hurts religious sentiments, contains scandalous or obscene matter, or is prohibited under the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, 1950.
  • For shape marks, the shape results from the nature of the goods, is needed for a technical result, or gives the goods substantial value.

The most useful answer to a distinctiveness or descriptiveness objection is the proviso to section 9(1): a trade mark shall not be refused registration if, before the date of application, it has acquired a distinctive character as a result of use, or is a well-known trade mark. Other arguments include showing that the mark as a whole (an invented word, a combination, a logo) is distinctive even if one part is descriptive, and offering a disclaimer of the descriptive part where appropriate.

Answering a descriptiveness objection

A hypothetical example shows how the arguments fit together. Suppose an application for the word mark "QuickPay" for payment software draws a section 9(1)(b) objection as descriptive. A reply might argue that the combination is not the ordinary way of describing the service, that the mark suggests rather than describes, and that consumers recognise it as a brand. If the applicant has used it for years, the reply would add an affidavit of use with sales and advertising figures to invoke the section 9(1) proviso. If the application was filed on a proposed-to-be-used basis, acquired distinctiveness is not available, and the reply has to rest on the inherent character of the mark.

Where the objection is to one descriptive word inside a logo, a disclaimer of exclusive rights over that word, with protection for the mark as a whole, is often a practical compromise. It costs you little if the logo is what customers recognise.

Relative grounds: objections under section 11

Section 11 objections arise when the examiner finds an earlier mark that is identical or similar and covers identical or similar goods or services, so that the public is likely to be confused. The report lists the cited marks by application number. Useful lines of reply include:

  • Your mark and the cited mark are different when compared as a whole, visually, phonetically and in idea.
  • The goods or services, their buyers and their trade channels are different, even if they fall in the same class.
  • The cited mark has been abandoned, refused, withdrawn or removed, which you can show from its status on the portal.
  • The owner of the earlier mark consents. Section 11(4) allows registration where the proprietor of the earlier trade mark or other earlier right consents, so a signed consent letter from that owner can resolve the objection.
  • Honest concurrent use or other special circumstances under section 12, supported by evidence of long, open use without confusion.
  • You are the prior user: your use began before the cited mark's application or claimed use date.

Combining arguments

A strong section 11 reply rarely relies on one point. Examiners compare marks as a whole, so a reply that dissects the marks into pieces and argues only that the suffixes differ tends to fail. A better approach shows the overall impression of each mark, identifies the dominant part, explains who buys the goods and how carefully, and then adds any status, consent or prior use point. Where the cited mark covers only some of your goods, offering to delete those items from your specification can remove the conflict for the rest of the application.

Check the status of every cited mark before you reply. A cited application may itself be objected, opposed, abandoned or refused, and a registration may have lapsed for non-renewal. Pointing this out, with the status page attached, is often the quickest way past a section 11 objection.

What a good reply contains

A trademark objection reply is a legal submission, so structure matters. It should include:

  • The application number, class, mark and the date of receipt of the report, showing the reply is within time.
  • A point-by-point answer to each objection, quoting the ground raised.
  • For each cited mark, a comparison table showing the marks, goods and status.
  • Legal grounds for acceptance: the section 9(1) proviso, section 11(4) consent, section 12, and any limitation of goods you are willing to accept.
  • An affidavit of use with exhibits, if you claim prior use or acquired distinctiveness.
  • A request for a hearing if the examiner is not persuaded by the written reply.
  • Signature by the applicant or its authorised agent.

Prepare your reply to the examination report

Answer each objection with the grounds and evidence the Registry looks for.

Draft a trademark objection reply

Evidence of use that actually helps

Evidence wins most contested objections. The aim is to show use of the mark as applied for, on the goods or services in the application, from the date you claimed, in a way the market recognises.

  • Invoices and bills showing the mark, spread across the years claimed and, ideally, across different States.
  • Advertisements, catalogues, packaging, labels and photographs of products in shops.
  • Annual sales figures and promotional spending, preferably certified by a chartered accountant.
  • Website archive captures, social media pages with dates, and app store listings.
  • Press coverage and trade directory listings.
  • If the mark was bought from someone else, the trademark assignment deed showing the chain of title, so earlier use counts in your favour.

Quality matters more than volume. A few dated invoices from each year, a sales summary and representative advertisements usually say more than hundreds of unsorted pages. Index the exhibits and refer to them by number in the reply. File the evidence with a sworn affidavit that explains each exhibit. Keep it consistent with the user date in your application: evidence that use began later than you claimed undermines the whole reply.

Step by step: replying to an objection

  1. Download the examination report from the IP India portal and note the date of receipt.
  2. Read each objection and check the cited marks' details and status on the portal.
  3. Decide your position: argue, limit the goods or services, obtain consent, or rely on use.
  4. Collect evidence and prepare the affidavit of use if needed.
  5. Draft the reply and file it online through the comprehensive e-filing system within one month of receipt.
  6. Watch the status. The Registrar may accept the mark, or list it for a show cause hearing.
  7. Attend the hearing (often held virtually) with your arguments and evidence ready.
  8. If accepted, the mark is advertised in the Trade Marks Journal and becomes open to opposition.

Do not miss the reply deadline

Missing the one-month window is the commonest way good applications are lost. Rule 33(4) lets the Registrar treat an application as abandoned if no reply is filed, and examination reports state this. In one 2024 case the Delhi High Court cancelled a registration that had been granted even though no reply to the examination report was ever filed, because the correct procedure had not been followed. Do not rely on the Registry overlooking a missed deadline in your favour.

The show cause hearing

Under rule 33(6), if your reply is not satisfactory, or you ask for one, the Registrar holds a hearing under rule 115. Treat it as a proper hearing: prepare a short written submission, bring copies of the evidence, and be ready to accept a reasonable limitation of goods if that saves the mark. Under rule 33(7), if you neither attend the hearing nor reply to the objection, the Registrar may treat the application as abandoned. After hearing, the Registrar passes an order accepting the application (with or without conditions) or refusing it. A refusal can be challenged further, which is where specialist advice becomes useful.

Before the hearing, re-read the examination report and your reply, and prepare a one-page note listing each objection, your answer and the exhibit that supports it. Hearing officers deal with many matters in a session, so a short, organised presentation is more effective than reading out the full reply. If the officer suggests a limitation of goods or a disclaimer, you can accept it at the hearing or ask for time to take instructions, but note what was said and follow up in writing.

Keep watching the application status after the hearing. Orders and acceptance notices appear on the portal, and any further deadline runs from them. An applicant who assumes that no news is good news can miss the next step.

After acceptance: the opposition window

Acceptance is not the end. The accepted mark is advertised, and under section 21(1) any person can file a notice of opposition within four months from the date of advertisement. If an opposition is filed, you must file a counter-statement within the time allowed; section 21(2) treats an applicant who fails to do so as having abandoned the application. If you spot someone else's advertised mark that conflicts with yours, you can use a trademark opposition notice in the same way. Licensing and transfers after registration are covered in our guide to trademark licences and assignments.

Objections based on a crowded field of similar marks, a refusal after hearing, or an opposition by a large brand owner are worth taking to an experienced practitioner. You can find an intellectual property lawyer through LegalFirms.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to reply to a trademark examination report?

One month from the date you receive the report, under rule 33(4) of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017. File within that period and keep the filing acknowledgment.

Does an examination report mean my application has been refused?

No. It means the examiner has raised objections or wants conditions. The application is waiting for your reply and, if needed, a hearing, and many objected applications are accepted after a reply.

Can I use the TM symbol while the application is objected?

The TM symbol simply signals that you claim the mark as a trade mark and is commonly used for unregistered and pending marks. The registered symbol should be used only after registration.

Do I need evidence of use if my mark is not yet in use?

Not for the reply itself. A proposed-to-be-used application can be defended with legal arguments about distinctiveness and dissimilarity. Evidence of use becomes important when you rely on acquired distinctiveness, prior use or honest concurrent use.

Can I change my mark to get past the objection?

Changes that substantially alter the mark are generally not allowed in a pending application, so a materially different mark usually needs a fresh application. Limiting the list of goods or services, or adding a disclaimer, is often possible.

Sources

The official texts this guide relies on. Laws and rules change, so check the current version before relying on any of them.

Documents to draft next

Real templates from our library, matched to what this guide covers.

You might also want to read